Key Takeaways
  • Key signs of a bad property investment include low rental income, property value depreciation, problematic tenants, and excessive maintenance costs. 
  • There are several strategies for exiting a bad property investment: selling the property through an estate agent, house-buying companies, or auctions, or renovating the property. 
  • To prevent future bad investments, it’s essential to learn from past mistakes, utilise property analysis tools, and engage in comprehensive due diligence.

Investing in property can be a rewarding journey, but not every step on this path leads to prosperity. There are moments when a property investment may not turn out as expected, presenting a challenging dilemma: how to get out of a bad property investment.


In this article, we will explore the key indicators of problematic property investment and delve into strategies for gracefully exiting such situations.

Signs of a Bad Property Investment

You may find yourself realising that your investment isn’t turning out as planned. This may be for any of the following reasons:


  • Low Rental Income
  • Property Value Depreciation
  • Problematic Tenants
  • Excessive Maintenance Costs


Recognising these signs early can help you implement property risk management before your wallet gets hit.

It’s essential to remember that having some of these issues may not inherently mean your investment is bad. Market conditions can shift, and unfortunate tenant experiences can happen even with thorough screening. To gain clarity on whether your investment truly stands as a poor one, consider using helpful tools such as our Buy-to-Let Analyser which provides in-depth insights into your property’s performance.

Strategies for Exiting a Bad Property Investment

Realising that you’re stuck in a bad property investment can be a tough pill to swallow, but the good news is that you have options for turning the situation around.

Selling the Property

When you’ve decided to exit a bad property investment, selling the property can be a strategic way to cut your losses and move on. There are several different avenues you can explore for selling the property, each with its own pros and cons:

1. Real Estate Agent

Real estate agents offer expertise and can manage the entire selling process. They can be particularly helpful when you’re not well-versed in the property market or if you’re looking for a smooth, guided selling experience. 


However, be wary of agents who guarantee to sell it above market value or those demanding suspiciously low rates; chances are they won’t be able to sell your house for months. Remember, buy cheap, buy twice; so if this route suits you, please do your due diligence.

2. House Buying Companies

These companies specialise in buying properties quickly, often in as-is condition. If you’re looking to make a speedy exit from a bad investment, a house buying company might be a suitable option. 


However, be aware that their offers might be much lower than the market value. They’ll often offer around 70% market value but could buy the property from you in as little as a few weeks (in comparison, estate agents take around 6 months on average).

3. Auction

Auctions can be an efficient way to sell a property, especially when you’re keen on a swift sale. Buyers in auction scenarios often come prepared, and the competitive nature of auctions can sometimes lead to a better price but this isn’t always guaranteed. 


However, auction buyers are often more savvy and will spot the bad investment from a mile away, thus adjusting their valuations of the property.

Selling with a Tenant In Situ

If your property has tenants, selling becomes a bit more complicated. Here are a few considerations:


1. Notify Your Tenant: You must inform your tenant of your intention to sell the property. In the UK, tenants have certain rights during this process. Typically, you’ll need to give at least two months’ notice.


2. Tenant Cooperation: While you have the right to sell, a cooperative tenant can make the process smoother. Encourage them to keep the property in good condition, be flexible with viewings, and provide access for inspections.

3. Tenant Rights: Remember that tenants have rights when their landlord is selling the property. Their tenancy agreement remains in effect, and their new landlord will have to honour its terms. This continuity can be off-putting to buyers if the rents are too low.

Renovating the Property

Selling is not the only option you have, you could salvage a bad property investment by refurbishing it. This approach can breathe new life into your investment by turning it into a profitable asset and increasing its resale value. 


However, careful planning and number crunching are necessary to determine whether it would be worthwhile. We’d recommend exploring the following guides for more depth on how to determine whether this would be a worthwhile avenue to explore:


Buy Refurbish Refinance Guide

Property Due Diligence Guide – This is especially useful.

How to Calculate the Market Value of a Property

As a quick summary, you’d want to focus on making the following:


1. Cost-Effective Upgrades: Focus on cost-effective upgrades that enhance the property’s appeal and value. This might include fresh paint, new flooring or perhaps a new kitchen. The goal is to make the property more attractive to prospective tenants or buyers without overspending.


2. Comprehensive Due Diligence: Assess the property’s current market value, the cost of renovations, and the potential rental or resale value post-renovation. Our property due diligence guide and free property analysis tools can be invaluable for accurate number crunching.

3. Smart Renovation Choices: When renovating for profit, avoid over-improving the property. Your goal is to achieve the highest return on investment (ROI) while keeping costs in check.

The Key to Successful Investments

Hands down the single most important step that you can take in your property investing journey is learning how to properly analyse deals. A bad property investment leaves you vulnerable to de-appreciation, loss of your hard-earned funds, and worst of all, hair lose caused by all the stress. If you'd prefer to avoid stocking up on Regaine, consider checking out our range of property analysis tools.

Tax Considerations When Selling Your Property

Since you’ve dubbed the property as a bad investment, I don’t think this would be the case but If you’ve made a profit on your investment, you’ll need to account for potential tax liabilities. 


If the profit exceeds £12,300, you’ll be subject to Capital Gains Tax. Basic-rate taxpayers are taxed at 18% on gains over the threshold, while higher-rate taxpayers face a 28% tax rate. 


Please note that this figure applies to all capital gains made by you as an individual so even if you only made a few thousand pounds from this property, you may still have to pay tax on it. For more in-depth information on CGT, please visit’s page on the matter.

Preventing Future Bad Investments

Exiting a bad property investment is a crucial step towards protecting your financial well-being and minimising potential losses. However, the true wisdom in this process lies in using the experience to prevent making similar bad investment decisions in the future. Here’s how you can turn a bad investment into a valuable lesson:

1. Learn from Past Mistakes

The first step in preventing future bad investments is to reflect on what went wrong with the current one. Identifying the specific factors and decisions that led to the poor investment can provide you with valuable insights. Did you rush the decision-making process? Did you skip due diligence? Were you overly optimistic about market conditions? Once you pinpoint these factors, you can work to avoid them in your future investment strategies.

2. Utilise Property Analysis Tools

In the digital age, property investors have access to a wealth of data and tools that can assist in making informed investment decisions. Property analysis tools, like our Buy-to-Let ROI calculator and the Property Flip Deal Analyser, are incredibly useful for assessing potential investments. 


These tools help you scrutinise the financial viability of a property, offering insights into factors such as return on investment, cash flow, rental yield, and more. They help you ensure that your numbers are correct before you commit to an investment.

3. Engage in Comprehensive Due Diligence

Due diligence is the cornerstone of sound property investments. Conduct thorough research on potential properties, their locations, and the current market conditions. The use of due diligence checklists can guide you through this process systematically. Additionally, tools like Lendlord’s postcode analysis tool can provide valuable insights into the local market trends, rental demand, and potential rental income.

Final Thoughts

Recognising and addressing a poor property investment is crucial for safeguarding your financial well-being. If you’re dealing with a bad property investment, take action, consult experts if needed, and plan your exit carefully. Explore our resources for more insights and tools to aid your investment decisions.

Victor Sterling

Victor Sterling

Hi, my name’s Victor - I’ve been investing in property for three years now, with my preferred strategies being buy-to-let, BRR and house flips. My goal with Amateur Landlord is simple - to provide beginners with easy-to-follow resources that simply weren’t around when I started, and to offer these for free and without ads.

Related Guides



The data and all content on this website is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon. It does not constitute investment advice, or advice on tax or legal matters.  You alone have the responsibility of carrying out due diligence to evaluate the benefits and risks associated with any content on this website and seek the appropriate professional advice. You agree not to hold this website, its owner, author or any sponsor accountable for any possible losses as a consequence of any decision you made, based on the information you found on this website. No income claims are being made for any opportunity or method described — outcomes often depend on personal skills and work ethic alongside market conditions that are outside of any individual control. This website is not endorsed nor sponsored by any company or band mentioned therein.